Showing posts with label books on writing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label books on writing. Show all posts

Monday, March 14, 2016

Writing What You Know and Researching What You Don't

Clips
Beginning writers are often given the advice "write what you know." It's not a rule, not by a long shot. It's advice.

And it's not even advice that applies  long-term.

It's training wheels.

When you're starting to write, you have a lot of brand new considerations to make. You're learning to balance craft -- storytelling, grammar, narrative, pacing, character, dialog -- and the best way to do that is to do. That is, write. And if you're spending the majority of your time researching, then you're not writing.

Further, it can become hard to parse if your story isn't working because of craft issues or because you're writing about something you clearly have no experience with. It's best to eliminate variables to help diagnose the problem. In this case, eliminating places, careers, time periods, situations, etc., that you're unfamiliar with, means that the problems that are left are probably craft problems.
​
So once a writer reaches the stage where her writing feels solid enough to take on research . . . well, that's a brand new, fabulous can of worms.


Research: it's like spinach for writers

You need to know what you're talking about. There it is. The reason we say "write what you know." You need to know what you're talking about. If you've experienced it, all the better. If you haven't, then you need to research it to make it something you know.

And there are three layers of knowing to consider: details/mechanics, emotions, and cultural/social structures.

Details and mechanics can always be researched. Start with a Google search. Read articles on the topic. Read books on the top (or the relevant parts of books on the topic). Visit the location. Visit museums or reenactments of the time period. Watch/read fiction with a similar setting.

You can find Writer's Police Academy events put on around the country -- very popular with mystery writers for obvious reasons. They walk writers through some routine procedures, let them learn what it feels like to be handcuffed, answer questions, and the like.

Of course, technical details can be gleaned from reading-research or watching-research, but nothing beats the real thing for the sensory experience. The smell, sound, taste, and feel of the thing/place can instantly make fiction real, regardless of how well we can "see" it.

Emotions. The way people react in certain situations and the ways they process information, grief, etc. -- those are much harder to do direct research on. The best research on this count is life experience. The more situations you've encountered in your life, the more you know about your own reactions and the reactions of others. Some can be discerned through people-watching, and some through really engaging with fiction, but nothing beats life experience.

Have you ever read something where the character's emotion seems totally off base and you just have to wonder, has the writer ever actually experienced the death of someone close to them? or falling in love? had their heart broken? been cheated on? lost a job? been told they had a life-changing diagnosis? been in combat? or whatever the situation is. Research/experience is important here too.

Not to mention social structures. Different social groups have different structures and rules that determine how people act. Be aware that characters from different backgrounds will act differently, whether it's a cultural, generational, or linguistic difference. I've seen good writers fail miserably while attempting space-based military science fiction. They love the genre and have a grasp of the science, but absolutely no experience with the military, and it killed the realism of the character interactions in that particular setting. Can someone who's never served write good military SF? Probably, but it'll take a lot of research and the help of experts.

Research makes writing stronger. Like spinach.

But like Popeye, you don't apply the spinach directly to the problem, you ingest it and let it work through you. Don't dump research directly into the writing, let it work through you. Let it become part of your character building and creative process. Let it become part of your body and brain until you use it unconciously.

And beware the infodump-disguised-as-dialog route. That's a bit like swaping coats and expecting facial recognition software not to find you. Savvy readers will be able to see right through that disguised research dump.

But research that's well incorporated can heighten the reader's sensory experience. Do you know what a morgue smells like? I don't. Not from personal experience. But a well-written scene could transport me there even if it's not an experience I really want to have firsthand.

Research: it's like entering the Fire Swamp

Do you know someone who's been "doing research" on their novel for years? When you ask how the writing's going, they tell you about this or that resource they've found and how it's inspiring them, but updates on the actual writing of the story are much more sparse.

Research, as wonderful and necessary as it may be, can become a Fire Swamp for writers that prevents them from reaching their ultimate goal: the writing.  Patches of lightning sand to suck you in and suffocate you. Spouts of flame. R.O.U.S.s that creep along in the shadows, tailing you, wiggling their ugly noses to stay on your scent.

The Fire Swamp is absolutely not someplace you'd like to build a summer home, but it is a place you could live quite happily for a while . . . so long as you get out before one of the three great dangers of the Fire Swamp does you in. Or rather, kills your chances of completing a project.

It's the twists and turns of research that suck you in so that you never feel like you've reached the bottom, that you know enough, and can stop researching. It's the spurt of flame that destroys one idea, so you move your feet quickly and start down a new path of research you didn't expect to go down in order to flesh out a second idea. It's the creeping doubt that you're not getting it right, you need to know more before you can proceed or the critics and experts are going to eat you alive.

You may have to traverse the Fire Swamp of research. Just remember, once you go in you can make it out.

But why bother doing deep research at all? Because Wikipedia is a wonderful place to start research but a horrible place to end it.

Moving beyond Wikipedia

Wikipedia, a horrible place for your research to end. Yep, it's worth repeating.

Wikipedia can't tell you what a morgue smells like. It can't express to you on a scale of 1-10 how itchy and uncomfortable a Civil War uniform is. It can show you pictures of the coast of Ireland or the Amazon rain forest or the Southwest, but it can't tell you how the air feels on your skin in those places or the wuzziness of altitude sickness in a desert is like. Nor is it going to differentiate between technical detail and day-to-day details of certain occupations.

Consider Wikipedia on par with asking your spouse or neighbor or co-worker, hey, have you ever heard of such-n-such, and then discovering that they have a good passing knowledge of the thing. Conversational knowledge. They can give you keywords and point you in the right direction as you continue to research and read things by actual experts that is more in depth than a Wikipedia article could ever be (and eventually you can contact those experts, more on that later). Whether those are news articles, journal articles, or books.

And no, not all those resources are going to be free.

Well, not free on the internet. But if you have a library card, you can bet your ass they're still free. You just have to do some work and carry your butt down to your library.

Only have a popular library in your town? No access to a research library (usually a university library)? Actually, you do have access to huge libraries even through a tiny little small town library. Most public libraries are connected to a state-wide network that connects both city and university collections. In Michigan it's called MeL Cat, the Michigan eLibrary Catalog. What you can do with that website catalog is take your library card, the one from Podunk Town, and use it to check out books from the University of Michigan or Michigan State University or whoever has the book you want. And best of all, those libraries will deliver the book to your local library for free. You pick it up and check it out using your regular old library card.

If you have access to a system like this (and again, in Michigan you almost always can get access and I have to imagine other states have similar systems), you can get access to serious, vetted, in depth resources, some of which would be expensive -- or impossible, if they're out of print -- to purchase on your own.

All you have to do is be patient and wait for them to be delivered. Use that time to write the next scene. You know, avoid feeling like you're building a summer cottage in the fire swamp.

When/how to consult an expert

In the Roundtable Podcast interview "20 (more) minutes with Jeanne Cavelos, the host remarked that Jeanne Cavelos had several appeals for help listed on her website's front page. One of which was for experts in scientific fields she was not herself well versed in, and another appeal states, "My main character is bipolar (manic-depressive). If you are bipolar and don't mind sharing some of your experiences..."

I agree with the Roundtable Podcast host Dave Robison about the absolute remarkableness of reaching out. As writers who are creating whole worlds in our minds or who are perhaps hard pressed to carve out time alone to do the writing, the idea that we then need to reach out to others is . . . tough sometimes. Such an easier route is to just jump on Wikipedia and call it done.

Jeanne Cavelos urged writers to do research, "whether to make the setting more real, the science more real, or the magic more real." And divulged that when she started writing she didn't want to ask for expert help because she felt embarrassed to not know.

She also shared what she's found to be the best way to approach an expert: gather as much information about the subject as you can before you approach the expert -- asking them to give you a crash course in the topic isn't useful or polite -- so that by the time you're reaching out to them they know you "just have some questions that only a person can answer." Even mentioning the time she contacted an expert in manhole covers after reading the book the expert had written.

Yes, an expert in manhole covers. There are all sorts of people out there with specialized knowledge.

It reminds me of an Anne Lamott essay in Bird by Bird where she recounts becoming obsessed with figuring out the word for the wire thingy on top of a champagne bottle. It's called a wire hood, by the way, but gaining that knowledge led her down a path that eventually had her on the phone with a monk who worked in a vineyard. Her point in the essay was that researching by reaching out to speak to experts makes writing more communal (which Wikipedia cannot do -- although  admittedly, she was penning the essay before the rise of Wikipedia).

"Sometimes I think I know the answer and I just want to confirm it," Jeanne Cavelos says in her podcast interview. "And many times they [the experts] volunteer details that are incredible that I want to incorporate in some way into the book. That's one way primary sources and experts can really help you, providing these details that you can't imagine and you can't find in a book. As writers, we tend to believe we have pretty good imaginations, but really the truth is often way stranger and more interesting than we can imagine."

I once heard from a paramedic who said he'd been prepared to see weird stuff when he'd worked in New York City, but hadn't truly seen weird shit until he started working the same job in Cleveland. And no, I couldn't imagine the details. Not without asking someone who'd actually been there.

Thursday, May 17, 2012

Creating the lie

I love this writing concept!  Outlined in this article, "creating the lie" is all about that thing that your character believes at the start of the story which isn't true. And, in essence, the entire story is about them going through whatever it is they need to go through so that they no longer believe the lie by the end of the story.

Why do I love this concept? Because it's a great way of tying together the action aspects of the story with the psychological aspects of the story. I often find myself writing critiques to other writers about how their climaxes have become all action and no emotion. Now it's true that I've come to agree to disagree about the amount of description that should be on the page concerning emotional reaction / character feelings / character's internal reaction to stimuli.(I'm a big fan of more! so long as it's engaging, because I want to feel as they feel, agonize as they agonize, pump my fist in the air as they rejoice.) But thinking of your character as "caught in a lie they must overcome" forces you to not let the climax be about action alone.

Yes, the climax is tense. Yes, the climax is action filled.  Yes, you're speeding up the pacing by trimming down exposition. But trimming exposition doesn't mean  you have to trim emotion. Actually, Monica Wood's book on writing called Description has absolutely awesome discussion and examples of just this, so let me say it again: amping up the pacing and cutting exposition does not mean you have to cut character emotion -- it just means delivering it in short bursts relative to the pacing of the action surrounding it.

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Searching, Receiving ... now if the universe could just deliver me a story before deadline

I've been searching for the Robert Heinlein article/letter titled "On the writing of speculative fiction," ever since Elizabeth Twist referenced it in her post earlier this week.  It's better known as "Heinlein's rules of writing."  All I can find of it on the internet are the rules themselves and that it's supposedly from a 1947 private letter to Heinlein's agent Blassingame.  I've contacted my father to see if it's in Grumbles from the Grave, which I remember skimming for a report in high school and recall having Heinlein's letters in it.  Hopefully I'll find it soon because I want to see the whole of the essay.

The Secret History of FantasyI also sent for and received The Monsters and the Critics, a book of Tolkien essays on Ursala Le Guin's recommendation.  no, Le Guin and I are not chummy -- but oh how I wish we'd discussed it over coffee! -- I have a long list of "seminal work to read" courtesy of Le Guin's essay in Secret History of Fantasy edited by Peter S. Beagle (and still available in book stores).  And the copy of Monsters and the Critics I bought arrived by Royal Air Mail -- apropos, I think.  In there is "On Faerie-Stories," his famous what is fantasy essay.

And ... I'll be up half the night finishing a short story for deadline.

I love having these weekly MFA thesis deadlines, but they also set a tough pace.  Yep.  Still lovehate deadlines. And I'm on another one.  Right now.  Okay, universe, time to deliver.

Monday, September 13, 2010

Write like a motherfucker

The much delayed "on writing" review post.

The Call of the Writer's Craft: Writing and Selling the Book WithinOver Labor Day weekend I finished reading the first half of Tom Bird's book  The Call of the Writer's Craft (which for some reason, Amazon.com sells but the posted picture is of the wrong book cover).  The first half deals with getting you to get the writing done, and the second half of the book deals with getting you to get your work published.  Make no mistake, Tom Bird wants you to be a working writer, not some namby-pamby artiste.

If Julia Cameron (The Artist's Way) is the writing world's kind, caring therapist -- maybe a little too woo-woo spiritual to be a true Oprah, but not too far off either -- and Anne Lamott (Bird by Bird) is the writer's Woody Allen, laughing and learning from her own neuroses, then Tom Bird is its Dr. Phil.

Tom Bird and Dr. Phil have the same no-nonsense approach.  I get the sense that Tom Bird wants you to do better and be happier, but he's not gonna hold your hand through months of therapy, he's gonna tell it like it is.  Namely: to write a book, you have to get in the raw word count.  The first half of The Call of the Writer's Craft is tips and strategies for getting over yourself and getting words on the page.

The Writing Diet: Write Yourself Right-SizeBird claims you can write a full length book in 3-5 weeks working two hours a day, six days a week.  When I first heard this I thought it sounded too much like an infomercial for a fad diet.  But the "real diet" science is being it.  Real diet = burn more than you eat.  Book in 3 weeks = getting several thousand words on the page every day.  I still can't figure out why I was originally skeptical; I've done NaNoWriMo's before.

Also quite amusing are Bird's asides where he relays success stories from people who've taken his class.  The best part of these tales is that Bird almost always describes each of these people as approaching him in a manner that he found awkward, annoying, off-putting or petulant.  Then he snapped them out of their annoyingness and they succeeded!  I have no idea how many writers the world can credit Tom Bird with helping (the number is likely written in the books somewhere), but it can credit him with making at least a dozen people less petulant.

Letters to a Young PoetSwitching gears from tough love writing book to tough love writing essay, there's this fabulous essay ... or should I say letter to a young writer--although I have to say that Rilke was never quite this forthright or fresh.  I like it.  (Found via Margosita).

Both pieces encourage us to write like a motherfucker.

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

In love with an essay

Check out Alexander Chee's essay "Annie Dillard and the Writing Life." I'm in love with this essay. I plan on saving it and giving it to my creative writing students to read ... when I eventually have creative writing students to whom I assign readings.

And, interestingly enough, Dillard, though Chee, finally articulates a reason for literary writers disliking gerunds. Previously it had been one of those "just avoid such-n-such" rules that I had headed but not understood.

Wednesday, March 25, 2009

(Ad)Verbs

Notes on Craft

"Adverbs are not your friend."

- Stephen King
Words Fail Me: What Everyone Who Writes Should Know about WritingToday my students and I will talk about "verbs that zing" and ones that "wimp out" courtesy of Patricia O'Conner and her lovely book on writing Words Fail Me. She also wrote Woe Is I (grammar for grammarphobes) which I have just obtained a copy of but have not yet read. One of these will be assigned in its entirety to my students next fall.

O'Conner is witty. She talks about verbs that feel like a dead fish or a limp handshake. Why say fell quickly when plummeted serves your purpose so much more aptly and in one less word?

Which brings us to the Stephen King quote from On Writing, seen at the top of this post: adverbs are not your friend.

I will reiterate what King and O'Conner and many a creative writing instructor has said: if you have to say it with an adverb then you're not saying it right.

Adverbs clutter up the writing as they attempt to make up for lackluster verbs. By definition, the job of an adverb is to modify the verb so that the meaning is altered. But there are so many great verbs out there to use plain, why attach modifiers to them? It's like buying a low end computer and then buying an upgrade for the motherboard, some kick ass speakers and replacing the monitor, then getting one of those ergonomic keyboards. Why didn't you just spend the money getting a nicer computer than spend the same about of money (in addition to your time searching out those "extras") as you did with the piecemeal contraption you've now made?

Thursday, February 12, 2009

Write Your Heart Out

From Kirsten Ogden on the KRblog:

Did I clock in enough writing time to feel good about calling myself a writer? Or, as Rebecca McClanahan might phrase it, Why don’t we write our hearts out? In her book Write Your Heart Out, she says “There are so many reasons not to write, it’s a miracle this sentence appears.” She then goes on to share all of the misconceptions about writing that help put it all into perspective when we writers are thinking it’s a good idea to enjoy a Diners, Drive-ins and Dives marathon instead of sitting in the chair. (Hey, I like cheeseburgers!)

Misconception #1: Writing gets done without writing.

Misconception #2: Writers have time to write.



Read the whole blog entry.

--

I'm reading two books on my train ride to Chicago today, The Dark Mirror and Straw Into Gold. The former is a fantasy novel (the first in a trilogy as these things usually are) that I purchased because it promised talk of the protagonist's childhood and bore a blurb from Sara Douglass. Douglass = my fave Australian fantasy author. The latter is yet another young adult novel assigned in my folklore/fairy tales literature class. BTW the paper for that class went fairly well. I guess that BA I have in BS does mean something. I'll wait for the grade to come back before I say how much it means.

Tuesday, November 18, 2008

Sucks All the Energy Outta Ya

A post by Tanya recently got me thinking, and the fact that I read it Monday night after my workshop for the week got me writing this post.

The MFA workshop sucks the energy right out of you.

Most weeks I leave and all I want to do is put on my sweats and pour myself a drink.

The one time I walked away feeling truly energized was the week my story was critiqued by the group. I had all these new ideas for where to take the story and how to build my modest story (which I thought was finished) into something really cool. And then I read the written comments and that bubble burst but that's another story for another day.

I don't really have the problem where increased knowledge of writing and how it works correlating with decreased reading pleasure. Yes, I notice theme more readily now and I'm much more aware of the mechanics behind the work that the author has employed -- reading The List after taking Tara Ison's workshop I could totally see all the elements of structure she taught us about employed in her novel -- but that is fascinating in the same way that learning how movie special effects is fascinating; it still looks lifelike on the screen even when I know how it's done.

Any thing much deeper than that doesn't occur to me when I'm in the middle of reading.

In the midst of reading I love being caught up in the moment, in the emotion, in the beauty of imagery or the tension of the conflict and I stay right there with the story unless the author breaks it for some reason. This is what I refer to as the joy and wonder of reading. What is referred to in a recent edition of the Writer's Chronicle as "good storytelling" (and how it is frequently missing even unadulterated literary writing). I rarely develop any sort of notion for analysis (psycho, literary or otherwise) during these read through and keep myself wholly focused on the wonder of an unknown story. Then if I sit down and care to still think about it after I'm done reading I'll find myself able to draw those analytical conclusions.

For workshop: I read; I experience the joy of the unknown story (usually); and then, I sit and analyze. I analyze whether the mechanics worked and I analyze some deeper level of the story to see if it's there and see if I don't have any comments that could help the author in later drafts develop one. Although, I firmly believe that a moving, emotionally engaging, well told story doesn't need overt levels of meaning and that the author shouldn't try for them consciously. The four levels of allegory are what high school English teachers apply to fiction; they are not present when the writer writes.

Then, in workshop, the class destroys my joy. My awe. And any sense of wonder I may have had in reading.

They are overly critical and cynical (and rightly so, they know what a shortcut looks like because they've tried them). They've read a lot. Most of them, myself included, either read slush for a literary magazine or they work as an editor on the program's literary mag. They've seen a lot of "good" stuff and they've seen a lot of crap. This leads them to viciously attack anything they perceive as a weakness in the story.

No, workshop is not for the tenderhearted.

They do it in the name of what doesn't kill a story in workshop makes it stronger in the next draft, but, all the same, I'm glad I'm not asked to reread these same drafts after we've workshopped them because there is no joy left in reading it once it's been beaten and snapped at from all angles.

One form of badgering that has become particularly prevelant (and disturbing to me) is the use of the word "device." Every element of a story is now referred to as a "device." If it is what happens between the beginning and informs how we get to the important part or why the important part even happens, it's a "device." Occasionally it's a "good" term: the author used a really subtle device here. But it never feels like a good term, it feels like the naming of a cheap trick. Someone used it last night, and suddenly the story we workshopped (not mine) felt less like this heart wrenching slice of life in the world of a widower and deer hunter and more like a clock, or robot, or remote control. Device.

Maybe "device" is an appropriate word though. Given how we discuss stories and the kind of suggestions these writers make it seems more like they view themselves as builders, tinkers and puppet masters. They want to see how they can engineer a character's past and his emotions to make a better mouse trap.

What should a writer be?

I don't know. And I don't want to be prescriptive about it.

At times I find Natalie Goldberg's zen based writing philosophy too zen for me and yet I do not enjoy the writer-as-engineer philosophy either. There has to be some happy medium, don't you think?

Perhaps this is why I find myself ever more interested in writing good genre fiction opposed to bad literary fiction (see Writer's Chronicle interview with Nancy Kress and Poets & Writer's article by Mike Chasar, available in print only): because the genre writers are storytellers, they harken back to that ethnological desire of ours to spin tales, that biological need to relate to others even if only through the page.

Thursday, August 14, 2008

Not a Bad Wednesday ... Scratch That. A Good Wednesday

Project Runway totally sent the wrong designer home. The whiny boy who keeps talking about how he has such impeccable taste (but doesn't) really needs to go home. He should have left last week and the fact that he's still around is more a testament to dumb luck than his skill. My father says the guy is still around because the producers think he makes good TV. But this kid is just whiny ... that's not drama, that's annoying.

Segue. Yesterday was a good day for me as a writer. I worked on a short story that I had begun at the Kenyon Workshop and realized that I'm a lot closer to having a finished first draft than I thought I was. Yea!

The story started off as a prompt from a picture of a woman walking in the desert. I've been jotting down notes on it then and again, thinking about the characters for two months now but I haven't been able to get back into it long enough to work on the story as a whole until yesterday.

The story is going to end up being a lot shorter than I thought it would. 2000 words isn't a terribly long story, but the style of this one is very brief, pared down, even. Then again I think my stories always surprise me with their length because they going from being all these pieces and scraps of fabric to being knit into one another, just one piece instead of taking up my entire workbench.

Length aside, I'm just excited that I'll have something to take to workshop now!

One of my goals for the summer was to have two new pieces of short fiction that were at a point that I could take them in to workshop. As someone who likes to write beginning drafts that skip around and don't always connect with the thought before, getting a draft to the point where someone else can read it and think it coherent is an accomplishment. I also hate workshopping stories that are honestly "first drafts." I want as much time to edit as possible so that I don't embarrass myself.

At this point I only have the one story finished, not the two. But I'll take one over none! And who knows, I might not use it at all this semester. It depends on how the workshop class is structured, I might not get the opportunity. One way or another, it is a good feeling to walk in with a back up -- one that isn't from my application packet!

I've heard tell of that practice as well: that sometimes when first year MFA candidates feel overwhelmed by grad school or stuck in a writing rut, they pull the writing sample from their application packet and bring it to workshop. That practice has it's pros and cons. Perhaps you've never gotten a chance to workshop the pieces you sent in with the application and you now have the opportunity to have knowledgeable people give feedback. Okay I can see that one. But where you're shooting yourself in the foot is that you're not using the time to write anything new. (Although you could counter that argument by actually writing just not bringing it to class.) An MFA is nothing if not time to write with deadlines to push you forward -- or so everyone keeps telling me. It's also an opportunity to learn and apply those skills to writing immediately. And you also have to consider the fact that your professor might have been on the application committee and, as I've discovered through impromptu phone conversations, they remember these stories.

I just wanted to walk in with a short story in hand just in case. In case I want or need to go first. In case I get stuck or swamped or pressed for time. And after seeing that it took me two months to go from original concept to a draft I'd be willing to let someone else read, I might just need a back up.

One last bit of great news: I got a copy of Writing Down the Bones, by Natalie Goldberg yesterday! I was in love with the book after only reading the preface and introduction. I'm tempted to read the whole thing in one sitting but I know that's not a very helpful way of consuming a book on writing.

Monday, July 14, 2008

Finally!

Notes on Craft

Finally! A constructive critique on what is wrong with contemporary literary fiction. So much of the bitching and moaning about lit fic is that it's dead. It's dying. No one's buying it and fewer people are liking it. Well, if this is the case lit fic has been pulling a Hamlet for the past 40+ years in that it keeps coming back from the brink to deliver another little jewel to all of us.

This is a two part blog by contemporary lit fic (gasp) Darin Strauss. Part 1 and Part 2 have been extremely thought provoking. Not in the I see the light! Save me Jesus! sort of way, but in it got me to rewrite the opening to a novel I'd been toying with for a while but I thought was too much like a movie and not enough like "literary fiction" for me to write. (And I think it's a pretty hot little beginning now, too.)

What got me going was the PTA laundry list that he describes. Seriously, it's an atrocious opening to a novel -- who wants to listen to PTA minutes ever? even if you're on the board you want to be someplace else when that happens -- but for some reason I probably would have just patiently swallowed it. I would have likely put down the book in the first thirty pages, but never would I have that God what an awful opening! Why isn't literary fiction giving me drama! And it might be because I'm (sadly) growing acclimated.

Strauss makes reference to
Dreiser — who understood the advantages of thrill-ride storylines — was also the first post–Civil War writer really to show poverty and the everyday defeat of American morals. He was a social novelist. And he wanted to get at the full spectacle of our native life with blood-and-thunder plots. ... Henry James, on the other hand, didn't write much about what his contemporaries feared, but what they actually lived through — the great trailblazer of psychological and artistic intricacy ... lyrically, and without relying on complex plot machinations or gauche devices.
and he refers to all this as the split that occurred after Melville. But more important than the split is the fact that Melville had it all. The implication being that contemporary writers should give it a go and try for that "all" thing.

I, sadly, read some other blog (where the commenters obviously skimmed the article and didn't latch on to the key points) and someone cried out salvation lies in genre fiction! All hail the pulp novel, it is our promise land! While I've got nothing against a good genre novel now and again, the way to make literary fiction go from boring to intriguing isn't to scrap it altogether.

Obviously, Strauss doesn't go far enough with his train of thought for the flock to understand where the promised land is. I don't think I've found it, but my guide through the desert is something from Robert Olen Butler's From Where You Dream. He states that the one thing genre writers have in heaps, the one thing they never forget to give their characters and share with their readers is yearning. The girl wants to fall in love, the boy wants to slay the dragon, the agent wants to stop the IRA terrorists and save his pregnant wife. So often literary writers forget to let their characters yearn and to let that come through the page. Instead they walk around entire novels just seeing faces and touching objects.

There's more to writing stories well than just writing well.

Wednesday, June 25, 2008

Suggested Reading from KRWW and Beyond

As promised long ago by my still scattered brain, I am posting the reading list I garnered at the Kenyon Review Writers Workshop, along with some other links.

N.B. Some of these stories were required reading for the workshop (the first four short stories) and the rest came up in conversation as examples, suggestions for specific workshop participants or recommended reading for everyone.
  • "Twenty Minutes" James Salter, from the collection Dusk
  • "Mlle. Dias de Corat" Mavis Gallant, from collection Across the Bridge
  • "Lady with Lapdog" Anton Chekhov, from Lady with Lapdog, and Other Stories
  • "Wigtime" Alice Munro, from Friend of My Youth
  • Ester Stories (collection) Peter Orner
  • Child of God, Cormac McCarthy
  • Poetics, Aristotle
  • Patty Jane's House of Curl, Lorna Landvik
  • Tales from Morocco (connected shorts) Tony Ardizzone
  • Eats, Shoots and Leaves (guide to grammar)
  • Underworld, Don Delillo
  • You Must Revise Your Life, William Stafford (although there was some contention as to the usefulness of this book on the list)

Should you be interested in a more poetic (and less self-centered) version of the events check out Parts I and II blogged on the Kenyon Review website by Kirstin Ogden.

Among other reads I feel are worthy of checking out is Barrelhouse online magazine -- and not just because I submitted something there just last night and they have the nicest, most succinct online submission form a mortal could conceive of -- because they have quite a bit of good online (read: free) content. Namely voice driven pieces of short-short fiction. Funny, brief, and to the point. Nothing long enough to bore you or make you click the back button. If you remember the name Barrelhouse, it's because they showed up in my suggested lit magazines post as a new-ish market highlighted by Poets & Writers - which oddly enough wasn't how I found them and their remarkableness.

Oh! And I came across a snippet of dialog I had written down from workshop betwen the workshop instructor and the workshop fellow. I could give the context, but it's almost more amusing without it, just imagine two people engaged in a very sincere conversation ...
Instructor: It might work better if you do gay.
Fellow: I can do gay.

Instructor: You don't have to do gay.
Fellow: No, I can do it.

I miss those people. Also priceless was Brad Kessler talking about how he has to sell his seven kids before he moves to Rome. He raises goats.

Friday, May 23, 2008

Writing Guides In Review

The three writing guides I've had in my hands most recently have been Escaping Into the Open: The Art of Writing True Elizabeth Berg, Writing the Popular Novel, Loren D. Estleman, and No Plot? No Problem! Chris Baty. None of them have bumped Bird by Bird from it's coveted spot in my heart of hearts as the most inspiring and helpful book on writing ever known to the 21st century (wo)man, but each has its own merits and is worth the time if you've got it.

Escaping Into the Open: The Art of Writing TrueEscaping Into the Open: The Art of Writing True, Elizabeth Berg, was lovely. She gets more into how to live and write while both living and writing than she does into the technical aspects of writing craft, but her angle does serve a purpose. And likely fills a void in the writing manual market that made her publishers gleeful. She also talks common sense about what to look for in a writing group, a writing instructor, how to be a writing instructor, and how to spot toxic friends - and not the kind that have been dipped in radio active waste and are now superheroes. Other than that, I can't remember much about her book.

It's been a few months since I gave it back to my lovely public library but I do recall wishing I lacked a conscience and could therefore slice out all the pages in her chapter about how to be a good workshopper: the part where she calmly discusses how it's not about you, the writer, it's about the story. And you, the writer, are not the story. That there will never be a "you, the story" just "you, the writer." It would have been a handy chapter to smack people with should they ever start walking that road or attempting to belittle other workshoppers by confusing the story with the writer.

Finding Writing the Popular Novel, Loren D. Estleman, was an unexpected treat. I picked it up, in the library again, thinking it was going to be some old, stuffy, utterly annoying guide that would have a stick up its ass while denouncing pretentiousness in writing ... but I was wrong! It wasn't a thing like other guides to "popular novels" that I've come across. Estleman writes in a clear no-nonsense way that assures me that if I told him I thought his style was "just cut through the crap" he'd do that grudging acceptance chin sticky-outy thing that older men do and nod.

He comes across as having this down to earth mentality combined with a Midwestern work ethic. The kind of man who could win the respect of any of my hardworking uncles even though he writes novels for a living.

Estleman goes through mechanics, dialog, researching, figuring out which story needs to be told, developing conflict, getting the hell over yourself and writing the damn story without whining, publishing, and figuring out who your reader is. All this in less than 250 pages. It's a good, tight, fast overview. If you can't get into the academic quides, and the Artist's Way is waaay too shisshy-foo-foo for you, then this may be a good place to start.

No Plot? No Problem!: A Low-Stress, High-Velocity Guide to Writing a Novel in 30 DaysAnd I'm going to wrap up with the ever so fun No Plot? No Problem! written by Chris Baty. Baty is the creator of NaNoWriMo also known as National Novel Writing Month which I've blathered on about on occasion (and, as a matter of fact, I'm about to embark on a cousin competition, SoCNoC, for the month of June -- see the kiwi bird icon to the right). NaNo was Baty's idea for taking the month of November and forcing himself, and his friends, to write a 50,000 word novel in that short period of time.

How long is a 50,000 word novel? Think Catcher in the Rye, Of Mice and Men,Fahrenheit 451 or The Adventures of Tom Sawyer.

No Plot? No Problem! -- also, conveniently 50,000 words -- lays out the story of how NaNo came about, and how it became a world wide thing that now thousands of people embark on every November. Some just for fun and some for profit, but mostly just to prove themselves (much like marathon runners).

When it comes to writing craft, Baty lays out some slap dash guidelines that will hold the hobbyist through the month long writing marathon. His voice and writing style are enchanting. I mean who doesn't want to keep reading something that has just given her permission to write a story entirely about "a pair of super-powered, kung-fu koalas who wear pink capes and race through the city streets on miniature go-karts?" The entire book is littered with such images making it a quick and uplifting read. His input and, more importantly, his pep speeches are good to have on hand if you're looking to embark on an intense month long writing journey, or even if you just need a quick pick up.

Up Next: A Memorial Day Special

Tuesday, March 18, 2008

Book Rec

I don't believe I ever commented on Elizabeth Berg's guide to writing Escaping Into the Open: The Art of Writing True. It's a really pompous title for a really lovely book.

Instead of tackling the tiny bits and pieces, the mechanics of writing like Gardner does, she focuses on life as a writer and makes this the niche that her book fills. Berg tells of how she balanced (or didn't balance) life while freelancing for magazines, her transition to fiction, short fiction and novels, how to find a writing group, how to approach a relationship with an agent, how to deal with jealous friends and jealousy in yourself, which of course springs from her experience with success and seeing friends become successful at a faster pace than yourself. And she does all this while raising kids and keeping her husband from sending a search party out to find his missing wife.

Escaping Into the Open: The Art of Writing TrueI give it my stamp of approval. It serves a purpose no other writing book I've found has.

Speaking of purposes, I'm currently rereading tidbits from Bird by Bird, Anne Lamott, to help me with my sanity and will to move forward.

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

Self-Help: Writing to Diet

It turns out that I'm getting pretty good at skimming entire self-help books in under two hours while never leaving the book store. The Writing Diet took me just under 90 minutes. Occasionally I feel bad about this. But right now I believe everyone deserves self-help.

Self-HelpWhich reminds me of Lorri Moore's hilarious collection of short stories titled Self-Help. Her story "How to Be an Other Woman" was fabulous. So was "How to Become a Writer" to a lesser extent. "How to Be an Other Woman" always makes me want to title all my lists clients to see regardless of what I'm listing. It's this fabulous little story that I tried to get my father to read it when I had a copy checked out of the library. Unfortunately I told him the title of the story and he was quickly turned off. No amount of swearing it was literary fiction not romance would get him to read it. But everyone should read it as Lorri Moore is one of the greatest short storyist of the latter 20th century.

The Writing Diet: Write Yourself Right-SizeAnyway! I saw Aquarius' post on The Writing Diet and decided to check it out. As requested, I'm posting my findings.

Cameron has adapted technique she introduced in The Artist's Way for unblocking that which blocks your creativity, known as "morning pages," and formatted it into 200+ pages specifically directed at food and why we eat. She did this because she noticed huge life changed happening in students of her 12 week class/program. Most notably, they got happier and lost weight.

At first I scoffed. I've tried writing in the morning and I'm shit for it. There's nothing in my head when I first roll out of bed and no one's cajoling slogans of how having nothing in my head makes it the perfect time to write free of impurities helps that. Free of impurities might be great for tap water, but not for me. When I wake up I have no words. People ask me things before my coffee and shower and I do not give them words back. I grunt. At most. Usually I just blink then shuffle away. But Cameron isn't asking for important words. She's not even asking for me to write them before my coffee and shower. She's happy to wait for me to wake up a little and maybe even steal words from the world around me to refill my brain. But what she wants is roughly twenty minutes of stream of consciousness writing. A time where you put your pen to paper and just go without thinking too hard on what you're writing. You don't write fancy fiction, you don't write anything important. You just jot down what comes to mind. You don't worry about spelling or grammar or leaving a sentence hanging. You just keep going.

Even though her students do this morning writing without ever sharing it with anyone else, they often mention to her that they have seen patterns emerge, or that they recognize thoughts that were floating around in their minds as actually being more important than they previously gave them credit for. Basically (though Cameron doesn't say this) it makes her students more self-aware. And through self-awareness they change their lives. They stop doing things that are destructive because they finally realize the cause and effect.

It doesn't take long before you realize that her methods would work well for any kind of addiction be it food or drinking or smoking or others. She also notes how many people fixed relationship problems they didn't even think they had before they started writing morning pages.

Cameron pushes further into the world of why you overeat or why you eat the bad things you do by asking you to keep a journal. It's a not a calorie counting journal or a book of judgement and punishment. Instead it's a place where you have to log every time you think of eating and what you are feeling at that moment whether or not you actually end up eating something. Again, it's more self-realization and self-awareness. You are diagnosing your own illness by identifying what triggers your eating.

In sum, it appears to be cheap, time efficient therapy if you're willing to be honest with yourself. Thankfully the only person you have to be honest with is yourself, although she covers group/buddy scenarios later in the book. She also covers big picture life stuff in the second half of the book and the whole thing is plastered with examples from students she has known.

Julia Cameron is an interesting self-help writer because she's definitely someone that society would normally deem as needing help of her own. I could be wrong, but from how she writes about herself it would appear that she's gone through bouts of serious addiction, depression and mental instability. She would be out of a job if she was your local pastor/politician, but as your new age get-in-touch-with-your-self guru she's getting book contracts. And more than that, we're listening. We are a strange society of double standards.

Highly Recommended